Accounts & products / Advice
Invest yourself, or use an advisor?
Schwab offers self-directed investing, automated portfolios, and advisor services. The difference is not just fees; it is who decides the allocation, who executes, and how much time you want to spend.
Three ways to invest
Self-directed means you choose stocks, ETFs, and orders. Automated portfolios allocate from a risk questionnaire. Advisor services add human planning. Responsibility and fees differ.
| Model | Allocation | Execution | Fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-directed | You | You | Time and control |
| Automated | System | System | Simple, hands-off |
| Advisor | You and advisor | You or advisor | Larger assets, planning |
Fees: management, fund, and trading
Advisory services usually charge a management fee; automated portfolios may charge less or none, but still carry fund expenses; self-directed pays trading and fund costs. Add all three layers.
| Fee | Self-directed | Automated | Advisor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading commission | May be USD 0 | Executed inside | Varies |
| Management fee | None | Lower or none | Asset-based |
| Fund expenses | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Advisory fee | None | None | Yes |
A USD 100,000 example
Assume self-directed fund expenses of 0.10%, or USD 100 a year. An advisory program at 0.80% plus 0.10% fund expenses costs USD 900. The USD 800 difference buys planning and execution support.
| Item | Self-directed | Advisory |
|---|---|---|
| Assets | 100,000 | 100,000 |
| Management fee | 0 | 800 |
| Fund expenses | 100 | 100 |
| Annual cost | 100 | 900 |
| Ratio | 0.10% | 0.90% |
How to choose
Self-directed
You have a strategy, accept your own decisions, and do not want a management fee.
Automated
You want to save time, accept a standard risk allocation, and do not need personal planning.
Advisor
Larger assets, tax and retirement planning, or help with execution.
The limits of advice
An advisor can provide allocation guidance, retirement planning, and tax coordination, but does not guarantee returns or absorb market risk. Check who can trade, who monitors, how fees are calculated, and how assets transfer on termination.
If the advisor also earns product commissions or recommends in-house funds, conflicts must be disclosed. Ask for the fee sources in writing and compare an advice-only fee with advice plus product fees.
Advisory services often have asset minimums; below them, automated portfolios or self-directed investing may be more practical.
Three questions before switching
Tax
Transfers may trigger capital gains; check residence and holding period.
Fees
New management, fund, and transfer fees can offset the apparent saving.
Authority
Discretionary and confirm-only models differ; know who can trade.
Five common questions
Is an advisor always better than self-directed?
No. Advice adds planning and execution support but charges a fee; capable self-directed investors may pay less.
Do automated portfolios charge a management fee?
It depends on the program; some charge less or none, but fund expenses and minimums may still apply.
Will an advisor place trades for me?
It depends on the authorisation; some programs require your confirmation, others are discretionary.
How are advisory fees calculated?
Usually as a percentage of assets, sometimes with a minimum. Check the official documents and agreement.
Can I switch models later?
Usually yes, but transfers, tax, and fees may apply. Ask before switching.
Sources: Schwab Hong Kong advice and account pages, public data checked 2026-11. Examples only. Independent guide, not affiliated with Schwab.